AdamSmith Posted July 11, 2014 Posted July 11, 2014 Lord Carey: I support assisted dying The intervention of the former Archbishop of Canterbury is a dramatic departure from the official line of the Church of England By John Bingham, Religious Affairs Editor 8:57PM BST 11 Jul 2014 The Telegraph Lord Carey, the former Archbishop of Canterbury, is supporting moves to legalise assisted dying, it has emerged. His intervention is a dramatic breach with the official line of the Church of England. It comes days before the House of Lords considers a Bill tabled by Lord Falconer allowing doctors to prescribe terminally ill patients a lethal dose of drugs. Lord Carey is expected to argue that upholding the sanctity of human life without regard to suffering caused in the process could go against the spirit of Christian teaching. He will point to the fact that Christians already rely on the ethical principle of double effect to justify giving terminally ill patients doses of painkillers which will ultimately kill them. The former primate, who publicly championed traditionalist arguments on issues such as gay marriage, has previously spoken against relaxing the law on dying. In the Lords in 2006, during a previous attempt to change the law, he warned that if assisting someone to end their life was allowed, it would soon be treated as casually as abortion. While many opponents of the proposal argue that Christianity forbids any assisted suicide, Lord Carey has been persuaded that the commandment Thou shalt not kill should not mean prolonging suffering. The Church of England distanced itself from his position but Lord Falconer, the Labour former lord chancellor, said it demonstrated that the Churchs official opposition to the Bill was not necessarily representative of its wider membership. It is understood that Lord Carey was moved by the case of Tony Nicklinson, the locked-in syndrome sufferer who fought a legal battle to be allowed to die, before starving himself. The Bill would not have directly applied to Mr Nicklinson as he was not terminally ill but it is understood that his case prompted Lord Carey to reconsider the wider issue. Last month, following a case brought by Mr Nicklinsons widow, Jane, the Supreme Court urged Parliament to review the blanket ban on assisted dying or face possible intervention by the courts on human rights grounds. Under Lord Falconers plan, modelled on the system in the US state of Oregon, doctors would be able to provide a fatal dose of drugs to patients judged to have less than six months to live. Patients would administer thesubstance themselves but could receive help if unable to do so. The process would require two doctors signatures. Lord Falconer said: The number of people who support this Bill is quite substantial even from practising and active members of the Church of England and also other churches such as the Roman Catholics as well as for example the Jewish community. The Anglican church at the very top, by which I have in mind the bishops in the House of Lords, has been quite opposed, but it has not been the feeling that they represent their congregations. Opponents of the Bill said they were flabbergasted at Lord Careys change of position. Dr Peter Saunders, of the Christian Medical Fellowship, said: There is no biblical precedent or justification for compassionate killing. There is a world of difference ethically, legally, philosophically and theologically between helping someone to kill themselves with a lethal drug on the one hand and proportionate pain relief or withdrawal of meddlesome treatment on the other. Bishop Michael Nazir Ali, the former Bishop of Rochester, and a friend of Lord Carey, said: We must not assume that we know when people are going to die. Lord Carey himself knows of individuals, that I also know of, who were given six months to live and lived for years afterwards. A spokesman for the Church of England said: The Church of England is opposed to assisted suicide. He said that the General Synod passed a motion in February 2012 which expresses its support for the current law on assisted suicide as a mean of contributing to a just and compassionate society in which vulnerable people are protected. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/religion/10963195/Lord-Carey-I-support-assisted-dying.html Quote
Members RA1 Posted July 11, 2014 Members Posted July 11, 2014 How does one become the former Archbishop of Canterbury? The answer seems to be to resign, die or no longer have the favor of the King or Queen of England. It was big news when the Pope resigned but apparently not so much when the Archbishop of Canterbury does the same. Best regards, RA1 Quote
AdamSmith Posted July 12, 2014 Author Posted July 12, 2014 One is hard pressed to recall when the Archbishop of Canterbury last made "big news" of any kind. Thomas à Becket is about the only one who springs to mind. Quote
Members RA1 Posted July 12, 2014 Members Posted July 12, 2014 An early example of not continuing to have the favor of the King. I neglected to include murder as one method of becoming the former Archbishop. Best regards, RA1 Quote
