Your mileage may vary, but for the type of men that I prefer, which are more muscular men, Lagoa is on par with 117, and the facilities are top notch. Fragata is more like Meio Mundo in terms of garoto and facilities quality. I usually go there once during a Sampa trip, and I have maybe met 3 memorable guys there, of all the times I've been.
I have at least 40+ times checked my luggage at lagoa for $10R and never a problem! Also, Lucky, you could have cut your transportation costs in 1/2 by using Uber! I have used it exclusively in SP for the past 1-1/2 years.
We are all different and Rob is one of my best friends, but I hate Fragata!! Different strokes...